Add some sweet goodness to your table this holiday season with a delicious, fresh-baked pie from one of these local bakeries in Tulsa. Each year, bake shops all around the city turn ordinary pies into works of art. If you’re looking for a more traditional pie, they’ve got you covered with pumpkin, apple, cherry, pecan, and more. If you want to take it up a notch this year, check out the Mile High Chocolate, Apple Pecan, and more. Grab as many holiday pies as you need from these amazing local Tulsa bakeries. They are sure to be a welcomed addition to any Thanksgiving table.
11/2021 by TulsaGo Staff
1306 E. 11th St., Tulsa, OK 74120
Maple Pecan CreamHouse-made graham cracker crust with a whipped maple cream cheese & pecan filling.
Classic Pecan PieJust like grandma's ... gooey, crunchy, and rich.
Peanut Butter Chocolate ChipLight & fluffy whipped peanut butter & chocolate chips inside an Oreo cookie crust.
There are a variety of slices available daily. Call ahead for whole pies or special orders. 918-764-8843.
112 W. Commercial St., Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Classic Apple PieBaked in a deep dish pie plate with a spiced apple filling & a flaky golden crust.
Old Fashioned PecanPecan Pie just the way you imagine it, with a flaky crust & gooey, buttery filling.
Strawberry RhubarbOur made from scratch flaky pie crust with a sweet & tangy filling, baked in a deep dish pie plate.
Space is limited so we will be accepting orders until we hit capacity. All orders are for pickup at our Broken Arrow location.
10032 S. Sheridan Rd., Tulsa, OK 74133
Pumpkin PieFresh baked traditional pumpkin pie. Also available in Gluten Free! $21.95 for Traditional. $27.95 for gluten free.
Pecan PieFresh baked traditional pecan pie. Also available in Gluten Free! $21.95 for Traditional. $27.95 for gluten free.
Apple Crumb PieOur apple pie with a cinnamon oat crumb topping. $21.95.
Please place orders online, call-in or in house by November 20th.
1502 E. 15th St., Tulsa, OK 74120
Pumpkin PieWe developed this delectable Pumpkin Pie recipe 15 years ago and it has been a staple in our holiday pies ever since. We have blended the sweetness of brown sugar with a whiff of fragrant cinnamon and nutmeg. We then punched it up with just the right amount of ginger and cloves to set off the richness. This iconic pie is perfect for your holiday feasts!
Apple or Cherry PiesOur apple and cherry pies are a blend of soulful southern cooking and pioneer midwestern tradition. Our double-crusted piecrusts are flaky and buttery and filled with an explosion of plump cherries or tart apples. Our nostalgic pies are reminiscent of Grandma's love and would make a great addition to any holiday meal!
Pecan PieOur Oklahoma grown and raised Pecan Pie is one of our best-selling pies. Our mouth-watering pie crusts explode with the flavor of vanilla, maple-y gooey-ness and are enhanced by the crunchy texture and warm flavor of caramelized pecans.
The Coffee House on Cherry Street or "CHOCS" as it is referred to by our Patrons, is a specialty bakery, masterfully offering GLUTEN-FREE, VEGAN, and TRADITIONAL pies, cakes, cookies, cheesecakes, and pastries. We take special orders daily. Reserve your spot today for your Holiday Party. Let us know how we can help!
207 N. Main St., Tulsa, OK 74103
Dulcey Pumpkin MousseChocolate crumb crust filled with creamy pumpkin cheesecake and caramel mousse, topped with freshly whipped cream (naturally gluten free).
Butterscotch PecanFlakey crust filled with dark brown pecan filling with rich bourbon butterscotch.
Mile High ChocolateOur take on the classic French silk pie piled a "mile" high with freshly whipped cream, topped with crushed cookie.
Preorder on our website today for pickup 11/10-11/24 ONLY.
1717 E. 17th St., Tulsa, OK 74104
Sweet Potato Pie with Maple Whipped CreamClassic sweet potato filling is topped with a creamy maple whipped cream.
Cranberry TartShortbread crust is filled with Cranberry curd and topped with sweetened whipped cream.
Classic PumpkinClassic pumpkin pie is topped with shellacked pecans.
Call 918-764-8298 starting November 1st at 10am to place orders for Thanksgiving.